Book REVIEW
“The Silent Patient” Should Have Kept Its Silence (was it really Worth the Hype?)
I am a sucker for books.
And after consuming quite a number of them, I’ve come to realize that psychological thrillers, murder mysteries, and stories that make me question everything, and play detective before the author reveals their cards are my kind of literature.
Now, I don’t know if this is a blessing or a curse.
Going into a psychological thriller completely blind is always a gamble for me. It can either be an incredible experience because the author manages to outsmart me, or a rather underwhelming one because I figure out the entire plot before the book has even warmed up. Unfortunately, The Silent Patient by Alex Michaelides fell into the latter category.
I’d heard so many people rave about this book. The writing! The suspense! THE PLOT TWIST! People spoke about the ending as though it would permanently alter my thought process. Naturally, I went in with expectations.
And perhaps that was my first mistake.
I think I was barely 5 chapters in when I started connecting the dots. The moment the two central characters were introduced, something about their stories just didn’t sit right with me. I couldn’t explain it at first, but I suspected there was a connection, and as the story progressed, my suspicions only grew stronger.
By the time the big reveal arrived, I was less shocked and more like, “Ah. So I was right.”
Now, was the book badly written? I wouldn’t say so. Was it engaging enough to keep me reading even when I had a pretty good idea of where things were headed? A little bit, I still wanted to see how the author would bring everything together. But did the twist leave me speechless? Not particularly.
And that’s where my problem lies. For a psychological thriller, especially one that has been praised so heavily for its plot twist, I expected to be caught off guard. I wanted to question my assumptions, reconsider everything I’d read, and perhaps stare at a wall for a few minutes after finishing. Instead, I got confirmation of what I had already suspected.
Maybe the book simply wasn’t for me. Maybe I’d read too many psychological thrillers and become unnecessarily suspicious of every character with a mysterious backstory. Or perhaps the hype had set expectations that were always going to be difficult to meet.
I also found the storyline rather familiar. The hospital setting, the secrets, the suspicious characters, the gradual unravelling of events… I’d encountered variations of this plot before. In some ways, it reminded me of a Freida McFadden thriller I’d read and another psychological thriller that had equally disappointed me.
Not necessarily because the stories were identical, but because I recognised the kind of storytelling being presented. Nothing particularly new or surprising.
So, would I recommend The Silent Patient? Yes, actually. Particularly to people who are just beginning their journey into psychological thrillers. I think it’s a decent introduction to the genre, and there’s enough suspense (for a newbie) to keep them turning the pages.
But to avid readers of psychological thrillers, people who have spent an unreasonable amount of time trying to solve fictional murders and expose fictional liars?
I’d say approach it with no expectations.
I don’t think The Silent Patient is a terrible book. I just don’t think it was the mind-blowing experience everyone made it out to be.
It was readable, engaging in parts, and certainly not a waste of my time. But was it worth the hype? I’m still not convinced.
Maybe the problem is me. Maybe it’s the book. Either way, I remain unconvinced.
I was looking for a psychological thriller that would humble me. Unfortunately, The Silent Patient was not the one.
5
8
More from this reviewer
Women Couldn’t Vote, So She Disguised Herself as a Man to Cast One.
It’s sad to remember that there was a time when women couldn’t vote. Imagine having opinions, intelligence, ambition, and perfectly good reasons to disagree with the government, only to be told that your greatest contribution to society was to loo...






Loading comments…