True

Book REVIEW

Shakespeare Couldn’t Have Written This

Contains spoilers — reveal review

How far would you go for someone you love? Would you lie for them?
Would you destroy your own life to protect theirs?
Would you live in guilt just to shield them?
Now, Don’t look at me weird.
I didn’t ask the questions, M.L. Rio’s book ,If We Were Villains, did.
it is one of those books that leaves you with more questions about human behavior than answers.
There is so much to learn from it, so much to question, but a little too much Shakespeare for an average reader. But we’ll get to that.

The story follows seven brilliant theatre students in their final year. Their lives basically revolves around Shakespeare, studying his plays, performing his characters and, eventually, without realizing, recreating some of his greatest tragedies in their own lives.

Friendships became complicated.
Love became obsession.
Jealousy turned ugly,
anger equaled danger
and before long, one of them is found dead.

Richard, one of the seven students, died under suspicious circumstances. The other six agree to keep the truth hidden, and Oliver, our narrator, eventually takes the blame and spends ten years in prison for a crime that wasn’t entirely his

SPOILER ALERT: James was actually responsible for striking Richard with a boat hook, causing him to fall into the water. But when the others found Richard still alive, they chose not to save him. They allowed him to die and agreed to cover up what happened. Oliver without being asked to sacrifices ten years of his life to protect James. And just when you think the story has reached its conclusion, we discover that James supposedly died by suicide, ( although his body was never found) leaving behind a letter , a quote from a Shakespeare book, that leaves us to wonder. did he really die?

Now, beyond the murder and all the drama, what I particularly enjoyed was how much this book explores human behaviour.

You see how anger can push people into doing things they never imagined themselves capable of. You see how jealousy can completely distort someone’s perspective, how obsession (even of something as simple as a book) creeps in quietly, and how love can make people do some genuinely questionable things. You also see how people respond differently to tragedy. Some fall apart, some run away, some become better at hiding, and some simply carry on with their lives.

Meredith, for instance (one of the seven), goes on to become a successful actress. Oliver goes to prison. James is supposedly dead. The others have to live with what happened. One tragedy, seven people, and seven very different consequences.

I also found the relationship between Shakespeare’s plays and the characters’ actual lives particularly interesting. These students spent so much time performing tragedies that, somewhere along the way, their own lives begin to resemble the very stories they study. They play villains, heroes, victims and lovers, but the lines between their performances and their personalities become increasingly difficult to distinguish.

And this is where I started questioning everybody’s sanity.
At what point do you stop playing a character and start becoming one?
Were they good at their roles because they were already just like the characters?
Were they wrong for deciding to leave Richard to die even when he constantly bullied them?
What was Oliver’s point in taking the blame? What did he expect?
All these frustrating questions strangely worked in the books favor.

Now, if I were to take points off this book, I’d probably take just one for accessibility.

This is not exactly a book I’d hand to someone who hasn’t developed a reading habit and expect them to come back thanking me. The language is dense, the Shakespearean references are plenty, and some knowledge of classical literature would make the experience considerably easier. Otherwise, you might find yourself reading the same paragraph three times and wondering whether you’re reading a novel or sitting for an English exam.

You either need to be a careful reader, an avid reader, or someone willing to pause and research a few things along the way.

I believe a second read would be more rewarding because there are details and parallels you might not fully appreciate the first time.

But that’s also what makes the book so concentrated. There’s a lot happening beneath the surface, and if you pay attention, you’ll find yourself learning from characters who are, quite frankly, making some terrible decisions.

My verdict? It’s a very good book. It’s thought-provoking, beautifully constructed and psychologically interesting. It might demand more patience, but it rewards the reader who gives it that patience.

I’d recommend it, absolutely. But I wouldn’t pretend it’s an easy read.

Because, really, it’s a book everyone should read, but not a book everyone can read.

Upvote 6 Views 8

Loading comments…

More from this reviewer

What is TwoCents? ×