False
Score | 42
In Literature, Writing and Blogging • 5 min read •
BEHIND CLOSED DOORS — PART 7.

“THE ONE WHO CAME BACK”


“Ask your aunt which one of you died that night.”


Nobody spoke.


Amara looked at the woman standing on the staircase, then at the little girl holding her hand.


She wanted to wake up.


She wanted someone to tell her this was all a terrible dream.


But nobody came.


Her aunt was still on her knees, crying.


“Tell me,” Amara whispered.


Her aunt shook her head.


“Please…”


“WHICH ONE OF US DIED?”


Her voice cracked.


The woman on the staircase chuckled.


“She's still protecting you. Even now.”


Amara turned towards her.


“Who are you?”


The woman's smile disappeared.


“You really don't remember me?”


“No!”


“That's unfortunate.”


She took another step down.


“I remember everything about you.”


The little girl tightened her grip around Amara's hand.


“Don't listen to her.”


The woman looked at her.


“Still pretending to be the innocent one?”


The little girl lowered her head.


Amara noticed.


“Why are you afraid of her?”


The girl didn't answer.


“Look at me,” Amara demanded gently.


The little girl slowly raised her face.


And then she said something Amara wasn't prepared for.


“Because she's the reason I couldn't leave.”


The woman sighed.


“Enough.”


She stretched out her hand.


“Come here, Amara.”


Amara stepped backwards.


“No.”


For the first time, the woman's expression changed.


Not anger.


Disappointment.


“You used to run into my arms whenever I called you.”


Amara's eyes filled with tears.


“Stop saying things like you know me.”


The woman looked at the photograph in her hand.


“Your seventh birthday. Do you remember the cake?”


Amara froze.


Seven candles.


Two little girls.


Her mother taking pictures.


The memory returned in pieces.


One girl was laughing.


The other was crying.


And someone kept saying:


“Only one birthday girl tonight.”


Amara pressed her palms against her head.


“Make it stop!”


Her aunt suddenly stood up.


“That's enough! You promised you wouldn't bring that night back!”


The woman laughed.


“I promised?”


She looked at the aunt.


“You were the one who made the choice.”


Amara slowly turned.


“Aunty…”


Her aunt couldn't look at her.


“What choice?”


A long silence followed.


Then her aunt spoke.


“There were two of you.”


Amara swallowed.


“I know that now.”


“No. You don't understand.”


Her aunt wiped her face.


“You and your sister were born minutes apart. Your mother loved you both, but after what happened to her…”


She stopped.


“What happened to my mother?”


The woman on the staircase answered.


“She died.”


Amara stared at her.


“Then who are you?”


The woman smiled.


“Someone who was supposed to stay dead.”


The hallway became painfully quiet.


Her aunt continued.


“On your seventh birthday, there was an accident. I found you both upstairs. Your mother was already…”


She couldn't finish.


Amara's voice became barely audible.


“What happened to us?”


Her aunt looked at the little girl.


“One of you was breathing. The other wasn't.”


Amara felt the floor disappear beneath her.


“Which one?”


Her aunt began crying again.


“I was told to save the one who was still alive.”


“And?”


“I carried you out.”


Amara looked at the little girl.


The girl was staring at her with an expression Amara couldn't understand.


“Then why is she here?”


Her aunt whispered:


“Because I didn't carry you out.”


Amara stopped breathing for a moment.


“What?”


“I carried your sister.”


The little girl nodded slowly.


“I was the one you left behind.”


Amara looked between them.


“But I'm standing here.”


Nobody answered.


Then the woman on the staircase began laughing.


A quiet, horrible laugh.


“Oh, my dear. You're finally getting close.”


She opened the photograph.


Amara could see it clearly now.


Three people stood beside the birthday cake.


Her mother.


Her aunt.


And two little girls.


But something was wrong.


One of the girls had been crossed out with a thick black marker.


Amara moved closer.


“Why is my face covered?”


The woman tilted the photograph.


“Look carefully.”


Amara did.


The crossed-out face wasn't hers.


It belonged to the little girl.


And beneath the photograph, in faded handwriting, were five words:


THE WRONG CHILD CAME HOME.


Amara's fingers began trembling.


She turned towards her aunt.


“Who did you bring home?”


Her aunt opened her mouth.


But the little girl answered first.


“You did.”


Amara stared at her.


The girl continued.


“You came home wearing my birthday dress. You slept in my room. You called her Mummy.”


Amara shook her head.


“No…”


“You even forgot my name.”


The woman on the staircase suddenly stopped laughing.


“That's enough.”


For the first time, the little girl looked directly at her.


“No. Not this time.”


She reached into her pocket and pulled out the old silver key.


Then she placed it in Amara's palm.


“There's one more room upstairs.”


Amara looked at the staircase.


“What room?”


The little girl whispered:


“The room where they kept the real photographs.”


Her aunt rushed towards them.


“DON'T GO UP THERE!”


But Amara was already moving.


The woman stepped aside as Amara approached the stairs.


Almost as if she had been expecting her.


At the top, there was a narrow hallway.


Three doors.


Two were open.


The third was locked.


Amara recognised the door immediately.


It was painted white.


Unlike the black door downstairs, this one looked ordinary.


Almost forgotten.


She inserted the silver key.


It turned.


Inside was a small bedroom.


A birthday banner still hung above the window.


Seven candles sat on a dusty table.


And on the bed were dozens of photographs.


Amara picked up the first one.


Two little girls.


Same face.


Same smile.


Same birthmark.


She picked up another.


The girls were holding hands.


Another.


They were sleeping beside each other.


Then she found one with writing on the back.


Her hands went cold.


It read:


AMARA AND AMINA. SEVEN YEARS OLD. THE LAST DAY THEY WERE BOTH ALIVE.


Amina.


That was the name.


The name the little girl had whispered.


The name that had made every light in the house explode.


Amara dropped the photograph.


Behind her, someone spoke.


“Now you remember.”


She turned.


Her aunt stood at the doorway.


But she wasn't alone.


The woman in the pale dress was standing behind her.


And between them was the little girl.


Amara looked at the photograph again.


Then at the little girl.


Then at her aunt.


“Amina…”


The girl smiled.


“Yes?”


Amara's eyes filled with tears.


“Am I you?”


Nobody moved.


Then the woman in the pale dress answered.


“No, sweetheart.”


She stepped into the room.


“You are the reason she died.”


And suddenly, from somewhere inside the locked wardrobe, a little girl began knocking.


Three times.


Knock.


Knock.


Knock.


A voice came from inside.


A voice that sounded exactly like Amara's.


“Please…”


A pause.


“Don't believe the one standing outside.”


TO BE CONTINUED… 🖤


2
views 8
comments icon on TwoCents 2 share

Other insights from ☘️Baby 🍀 Joy ☘️

Contributor Points

Points-to-Coupons

Referral Earning


Insights for you.
What is TwoCents? ×